I loved Epitaph One. I had been warned it was an 'end of series' episode so watched S1, S2, E1, E2. I think little!Caroline worked in the sense of E1 only. If the show had never continued, we could at least be assured that Caroline lived on in SOME format even if we didn't know what happened to the original.

Paul's death shocked me but it's Joss, so I was expecting someone to die. It was Topher's death that ripped out my heart, even though it made sense. I wanted him to get better. :( (And then stay with Adelle forever.)