OMG POLL

[mrv3000]

Another poll on the internet has popped up, and you know what that means! FEELINGS. XD

BBC America Poll of Mens - David Tennant vs. Matt Smith

I love some of the comments. Apparently the only reason you could possibly vote for DT instead of MS is because you're one of those fangirls who just thinks he's hot.

Comments

[papilio-luna.livejournal.com]

lolol because no one has ever found Matt Smith to be hot ever. OMG internet, you never fail to astound me.

[http://users.livejournal.com/_thirty2flavors/]

I don't know why people are excluding the possibility of me voting for David Tennant because I genuinely like him and I think Eleven is terrible.

(I mean, not Matt Smith. I actually really like Matt Smith. But Eleven? LOLOLOLOL nope. ))

[chloris.livejournal.com]

Apparently the only reason you could possibly vote for DT instead of MS is because you're one of those fangirls who just thinks he's hot.

Well, of course that's it! Is there any other reason? *scratches head* I'm quite certain appreciation of hot men is the only reason women do anything and it's certainly the only thing we ever notice.

[fauxkaren.livejournal.com]

Personally, I voted for David Tennant to spite the people who said people are only voting for him because he's attractive.

[lyssie.livejournal.com]

ISN'T HOTNESS THE WHOLE POINT?? omg, fangirls, get off my siiiide (CAN I VOTE FOR JON PERTWEE INSTEAD?)

[got_swagger]

A tiny part of me voted just to be contrary. And because I love DT's absolute dorkery and fan-boy antics. And he has a pretty voice. (Not because he's hot - dude is WAY too pretty for my tastes. Attractive? Yes. Hot and sexy? No.) And his story of the Doctor wasn't the convoluted hot mess of a fustercluck that MS's is thus far.

*Laments that she couldn't have voted for CE*

[larxene-12.livejournal.com]

I admire them both separately, but I'd have to choose Tennant over Smith; yeah, he's more attractive, but Tennant is way more talented and and diverse than Smith. Isn't it a talent competition as much as a beauty pageant?

[six.livejournal.com]

That, and apparently you're stuck in 2009. lol internet.

[tripocket.livejournal.com]

I think I may be the only person alive that simply finds Matt Smith creepy. I can't watch him in interviews without cringing, and I can't watch him as the Doctor because he's just Matt Smith. I doubt I would have watched Sherlock if he had been John Watson. I have the same aversion to Jim Carey and Tom Baker. Yes, that Tom Baker... the one most people love. I'm sure they are all completely pleasant people and I know the issue is all mine, but it made it very easy for me to vote.

[amberfocus.livejournal.com]

I don't find David Tennant to be particularly hot. Attractive in a boyish way and a really good actor that can pull my heart apart, yes. I suppose in his own way, Matt Smith is similar, but not as...hmm...weathered? Broken in? Maybe just terribly young and less experienced as an actor for such a big role that has been a horrible mess since Moffat took over not been well managed by the writing staff of DW these last few years. He has made me cry once. David Tennant made me cry a few times. But hotness for either of them? No. Give me Christopher Eccleston or Paul McGann and I will show you hotness. As for being one of those fangirls? I've been watching the show since 1974 when I was four. I still think Ten was a better acted and written Doctor than Eleven and that DT is a better, more engaging actor than MS, but again, that's experience. MS has the potential to be great given writers that could plot properly.

[acciochocolate.livejournal.com]

I'm with Jack. I used to have an icon of that scene.